Vision, Aims, Objectives & Outcomes (Q1)
These aims really need to be embedded and developed more vigorously. Instead priorities seem often to be distorted, e.g. towards car drivers, volume house builders (who only build to the days standards) and too much support for retail businesses, whose business models are actually inimical to town centre regeneration (the convenience economy – the drive by economy – the pound shop economy).
Town Centre Regeneration requires local residents to have a stronger stake, which at present they don’t really have. Town centres should be good places to live and play, as well as work.
A stronger focus on enabling economic development and high value jobs in e.g. in IT and creative industries might be a good place to start, not part time work of retail / zero hours contracts with large corporations and their elaborate tax avoidance schemes.
With East Lothian being a highly desirable place to live, and to relocate a business to this hardly seems an impossible proposition.
Sustainability & Climate Change (Q2)
There are no alternative options, apart from doing nothing, I guess.
Passive housing needs to be built and creating an infrastructure that creates and environment that will attract inward investment and support local employment (but not retail).
Reducing the need to travel comes into it, and this is not well served by current models of building/planning which force people to rely on the private motor car, i.e. isolate people in difficult to reach estates that lack any infrastructure beyond a playpark. A mandatory emphasis on walkability and integrated or alternative transport options should be in place rather than as an add on options, dropped at the first hurdle.
Development Locations (Spatial Strategy) (Q3)
I went for the preferred approach. This seems like the better option leavened only by the fact that investments channelled to the new town will no doubt reduce funds to regenerate older settlements. But you cannot have your cake and eat it, though it could be argued that higher tax receipts should offset, they probably won’t as they’re a small proportion of the grant in aid.
The reasonable alternative could actually build-in mitigation options, to reduce weak sustainability, mainly on the transport side.
Town Centres (Q4)
Yes, the preferred approach.
Broadly a New Town Centre is a probably the better idea than trying to put pressure on existing Town Centres, which are poorly equipped to deal with the status quo (though this could be changed, e.g. by restricting car travel, car parking charges or reductions in short term on street car parking). Getting people to shop locally is a reasonable proposition. However, support for Town Centres needs to be translated into a better and different policy than hitherto. Too much emphasis is invested in supporting traders which are not really viable on the one hand (business rate relief treats small businesses as if they were a rare breed – they are not) and locally shop rents are not that expensive which means that barriers to entry are TOO LOW. Many traders undermine High Streets as good places to live (e.g. in no particular order I would finger: convenience format and chain stores, betting shops, pubs, pound stores and takeaways).
Living High Streets are going to be relatively car free, accessible on foot, by bike and served by proportionate public transport options. We don’t need a bus a minute competing for road space and polluting at the same time (decrepit double deckers that are ferrying mainly thin air are the worst). Long distance routes are better served by trains and buses should concentrate on reconnecting villages and local locations in an integrated way (meeting trains), supporting remote and rural as well as invigorating sustainable tourism, which implies also distributing the benefits, which seem to go to only one town.
All this would alleviate the parking problems (though really these are not as acute as many seem to make out). Dunbar for starters could do with more space for the disabled, bicycle parking, trees and seating lining the streets rather than private cars. Pedestrianisation and reduction of speeds to 10mph. Fewer convenience stores and better controls on the night time and takeaway economy. Most short journeys by car could be replaced by walking, or cycling. Although Dunbar has a strong cycling community, few cycle to the town itself, as it is universally perceived as unsafe, with too many cars and delivery vehicles usurping the public space. Delivery vehicles perhaps should have higher priority. Residents should have a better allocation, with resident parking schemes, which are the norm everywhere else, but not in this county. Better targeted investment in the public realm rather than wasting money on marking streets, excessive lighting schemes which are polluting the night sky, pointless signage and OTT road schemes (I can think of much pointless traffic calming).
I would like to see resident associations for High Streets to ensure that traders don’t wreak havoc. I would like to see greater emphases on protection of the Conservation Areas, which doesn’t mean that high quality design of the modern idiom is kept out, but rather the policies for vernacular and listed buildings are properly enforced and unthinking intrusions not permitted.
I would like to see proper stewardship of the built heritage vested in a community based body such as a Heritage Society. I would like to see greater emphasis on good old fashioned civic gardens, that appeal to mature audiences not just five year olds, with quiet areas that are free of playpark type infrastructure.
I would like to see trees replace some of the traffic infrastructure. Pocket parks and public amenty created instead of the alienation of ever more car parks.
Planning for Employment (Q5)
Again I went for the Preferred Approach with the caveat of no support for retail on these sites.
Planning for Housing (Q6)
Preferred Approach
Green Belt (Q7)
Neither
The green belt needs to be preserved only where there are objective qualities worth preserving (landscape, nature, history, place or the possibility of its development as one of the former), not because of a line on the map.
I suppose the mitigatory AND “If new long term and defensible green belt boundaries could be defined” implies that?
Countryside Around Towns (Q8)
In terms of the potential to introduce Countryside Around Town designations as a new policy approach, do you support the preferred approach, the reasonable alternative, or neither?
Preferred Approach
Room for explanation of answer and alternative suggestions:
This is an interesting notion. Dunbar, for example, has little urban green space provision according to the last audit, but arguably close enough to the countryside that it does not matter (it does!). However, the countryside around Dunbar is not as accessible as it could be, with coastal footpaths which are not easy to use because of conflicts with golf courses and lack of decent path networks. Preserving decent chunks of countryside – a green belt of sorts – could help to promote access, with all the concomitant public benefits that this could bring.
Central Scotland Green Network (Q9)
In terms of approach to the Central Scotland Green Network in East Lothian, do you support the preferred approach, the reasonable
alternative, or neither?
Preferred Approach
Room for explanation and alternative suggestions:
A balanced development of housing and employment needs balanced with detailed plans, not just strategies. There is a long term strategy in the draft Environment Strategy for example, but this is largely dominated by broad sustainability issues and preoccupied by carbon reduction, rather than protecting and managing land assets. I wonder how well the target relating to increasing forest cover by 50% has been met? While it contains a substantially irrelevant section on organic soils and wetlands, which don’t cover a great deal of land (uplands aside – where local authority policies would probably not really have an impact).
Priorities for green network in East Lothian or for your local area:
Woodlands and public path / cycle path networks, making it possible to connect villages and towns without using dangerous roads.
Development in the Countryside and on the Coast (Q10)
In terms of the approach to managing development in the East Lothian countryside and on the coast, do you support the preferred approach, the reasonable alternative, or neither?
Reasonable Alternative
a) and b)
Room to explain any alternative suggestions:
Explanation of answer:
Dunbar Cluster (Q15)
Do you support the preferred approach to new economic development and housing opportunities in the Dunbar cluster?
I have no idea really about deliverability, but it does sound like a complex proposition which has rather a lot of dependencies. Broadly, if improvements in rail services can be secured – at least trains once an hour, connections to Dunbar rail station by small bus shuttle (hydrogen fuelled?) and the extension/adoption of the station car park, then this is entirely practicable.
If housing is put in place and it is business as usual then we basically accept the consequences and will witness further decline of the town centre, with its emphasis on convenience and a low quality offering.
Funded by the developers.
As close as possible to the existing.
This isn’t an exercise that lends itself to voting, as your audience will be highly skewed (one way or the other). Broadly all these sites have merit and there is devil in the detail. Many locals will naturally disagree, especially if the building take place in their backyard. It would be useful to subject the list to a detailed assessment of the transport options, as this would probably negate some of the sites as potentials. I favour a mix of densities, closer to the town but which leave enough greenspace and de-empasise wide roads and car parking. There needs to be a wider range of high quality housing at both ends of the price spectrum to engineer a good social mix. Concentrating social housing in the old town has disbenefits and ghettoises the poor.
There are few sites in the town that are still waiting for development. I am personally keen to see some of these become town greenspace instead, as there is so little. Most social housing has been built with no garden or greenspace, or only nods to it. This doesn’t invite people to interact positively with their place, rather the outside world is a place to park your car, let your dogs defecate and dump your rubbish.
The main issue with expansion is transport. Indisputably there will be pressure to rely on the motor car as the principal means of transport. This merely perpetuates a culture of reliance on the car, out of town shopping. Town centres then become secondary retail centres, but lack serious investment and serious businesses. A car culture is not beneficial to the town centre residents, as town centres are merely conduits for cars or linear car parks. Many council policies are generally hostile to town centre residents (unbridled retail developments, underinvestment in the public realm, too much concentration of funding on a few expensive showcase buildings, weak / poor protection of built heritage, lack of green space, an assault on street trees where they exist, and in Dunbar specifically the Dunbar Conservation Area, imbalance of emphasis on needs of small traders and takeaways, which deliver few public benefits, exaggerated emphasis on car parking).
Housing Land Requirements and Housing Land Supply (Q18)
Is this an exam question? Broadly the approach looks plausible. The devil is in the detail of course.
Developer Contributions (Q19)
Surely you need an approach which gives the greatest public benefit, but which gives the planning authority latitude to vary the formula based on on cumulative impact.
Affordable Housing Quota (Q20)
That higher target won’t be met, without a different approach and funding. The 5 or more dwelling threshold seems rather low.
Affordable Housing Tenure Mix (Q21)
??
Energy, Including Renewable Energy (Q22)
Broadly support, but think that Gas fired Station is a short term fix, when renewable infrastructure is more urgent and would give longer term benefits. It is a great pity that CHP and district heating, heat from renewables etc have played a a small part hitherto. Instead we may find ourselves as net importers of waste to feed an incinerator locals don’t want and that still has not heat plan.
Use of Low & Zero Carbon Generating Technologies in New Buildings (Q23)
Building for the future needs surely higher standards that meeting current standards, or exceeding them by a very small percentage. Passive housing.
Minerals, Including Aggregates & Coal (Q24)
Aggregates and coal should be left in the ground, for future generations (option value).
Waste (Q25)
Any policy which ensures that EL doesn’t become a magnet for Scotland’s Waste would be a good thing.