Decriminalising parking enforcement is a welcome measure and long overdue. With the consultation on what to do, a year after Police Scotland gave notice to its wardens – who knows at what financial and human cost – completed, its worth reflecting on the issues.
There has been little change in the availability of ‘short stay’ parking locally, despite the lack of wardening. This is not because the Police have been issuing tickets instead it is because enforcement levels have always been low, abuses legion. A relatively small number, mainly shop keepers abuse the laissez faire regime.
I would be would be surprised if there was any substantial evidence that fewer people use East Lothian town centre shops/facilities as a result of the Police decision or that this is at all impacting on “town’s overall wellbeing and vibrancy”? In fact when I visit North Berwick it is always bustling. The problem here is that too many people are unprepared to walk very far to their destination. Given the generally good and almost entirely free parking facilities available in East Lothian, parking is not likely to be the critical factor affecting vibrancy. Selection of shops (what people say they want isn’t the same as need or what they get) and the general appearance of certain towns are more important and critical factors (not all are welcoming). Shabby frontages, leaky gutters, even minor littering and a feeling of neglect and decay affect people’s willingness to shop locally. I would be highly surprised if there was any hard evidence of decline, other than heresay and anecdotal stories repeated as if they were fact.
Local shops and businesses are much more likely to be adversely effected by general trends in the economy (asymmetrical uptick means many places are not seeing improvements) and structural adjustments (the internet) as well as changes in consumer behaviour (convenience, out of town). I’d be surprised if there is any statistically robust information that enforcement has had an effect one way or the other. It is as likely as not that the weather affects the vagaries of High Street shops to a greater extent than enforcement.
Indeed there is evidence that enforcement, as measured by the # of tickets issued before Police Scotland took the decision, was in decline to the point that it was no longer effective (and perhaps not raising enough revenue.)
Loading bays and bus stops are generally regarded by too many drivers as legitimate places to park, and locally we see delivery drivers (a growing problem with the rise of the internet delivery service) being the worst offenders. Mainly the problem is that delivery drivers have very tight schedules and targets, quite
unrealistic if you are to believe what they say to you. With non deliveries to private customers accounting for a large number of trips, this increases the number of unnecessary journeys and aggravates the situation.
But there is another view that there can never be enough delivery bays, just like there cannot be enough spaces to park cars. Unless of course the visiting public is encouraged not to park in town centres at all. This would be no bad thing, and could encourage walking and use of public transport. Supply side measures to reduce parking availability could actually be more helpful and make town centres safer, more welcoming, less polluting and generally better places to live, work and play in. Now that potentially would make town centres more vibrant, although this would require significant behavioural changes by the public and would be resisted by shop keepers.
That vehicles are parked in unsafe locations and may restrict traffic movement and reduce visibility for drivers / pedestrians is not new, and no better of worse than before. Again it is delivery drivers that are the worst offenders, including large corporates, like the co-op who service shops and locations that were never designed for volume and fast moving goods. This has never been properly enforced.
It is regrettable that many drivers believe that spaces reserved for blue badge holders, which are not used are available for other drivers. It would be no bad thing if there were more spaces for BBH.
Indeed it might be better that town centre parking was reserved entirely for BBH customers, very short stay – 15 minutes, for deliveries, and also for residents – for whom there is little or no provision in East Lothian.
It might be politically unpalatable, but parking charges in town centres themselves would encourage people to use existing parking facilities. This might then make enforcement pay for itself.
By and far the most important factor in affecting the vibrancy of a town centre is whether it is a good place to live and whether the shared space and public realm is respected by all stakeholders. If a town centre is full of takeaways and convenience stores it encourages and drive through economy, not dissimilar to a drive-thru McDonalds but on a larger scale, which is altogether counter to most of the policies whether for conservation and enhancement on the one hand and sustainable transport on the other.
Hence my ratings are medium. The coastal rating is low, not because I disapprove of coastal charges, but because the impact of abuses affects fewer people than in town centres. At least people are getting out and about, while most town parking abuses at a guess are out of sheer laziness on the one hand and a complete disregard for other users on the other.
It would be interesting to see at what level parking enforcement effort has to be set in order for it to raise enough revenue to generate a significant surplus to generate tangible and visible improvements in a locality, so that the public would be able to support it. “This pocket park was created with revenue from parking abuses, and helps us maintain it!”
It would also be interesting to see if enforcement could be a precursor to parking charges in town centres, however politically unpalatable that may be. The inconvenience and negative impacts to other stakeholders of inconsiderate parking (a slightly wider issue) are more often understated, and too rarely taken into consideration.